Doctor Who: Fugitive Of The Judoon Review

Spoiler: Contains Judoon. Also my spoiler-heavy thoughts on the fifth episode of the latest episode of Doctor Who.

There’s a very great deal to unpack in this week’s episode, but as is customary around these parts, I like to provide some spoiler space, so that if you’ve landed here before seeing Fugitive Of The Judoon, you can gracefully back out. Beyond the YouTube embed lie spoilers. And also Judoon, but given they’re in the title that’s not much of a spoiler.

Wow. There really was a lot in that episode to unpack, as well as an awful lot of foreshadowing for what’s going to take place in the final four episodes of the series. Or maybe the next couple of series, I guess, but you know what I mean.

So in order to break the tension, I’m going to break up my thoughts on Fugitive Of The Judoon with a selection of classic gags from the Big Book Of Judoon Jokes (“Bo Bo Sho Fo Ho Ho Ho” in the original Judoonese).

Q:What weapon did the Judoon Military Commander use on the primitive planet?
A: A Bo.

From the trailers, you could be forgiven for thinking that Fugitive Of The Judoon would just be another self-contained episode in classic Doctor Who style. That’s not the case of course, with the Fugitive being “The Doctor” — a mystery to be solved — as well as the return of a character who’s effectively a “classic” character, given we’ve not seen Captain Jack in mainstream Doctor Who for a decade now.

I can't have been the only one to think that Graham was teleported by the cupcake, right? I've never trusted cupcakes.
I can’t have been the only one to think that Graham was teleported by the cupcake, right? I’ve never trusted cupcakes.

I’ll be honest; my reaction to seeing John Barrowman — well, hearing him at first, but that’s a very distinctive fake American accent — was to cheer, because it’s been such a long time. The powers that be certainly did a good job of keeping what amounts to a cameo quiet, and I appreciate that, because it would have had so much less impact if I knew it was coming. Feels like something of a copout not to have Captain Jack actually meet the new Doctor, even if the scenes with Graham and Yaz were a lot of fun.

Q:Which professional wrestler is the Judoon’s favourite?
A: Samoa Joe (Joe Joe Joe)

(Joke credit: She knows who she is. Not my joke.)

What I did appreciate in Fugitive Of The Judoon was that while it did a lot of legwork for setting the story arc for the season, it didn’t feel the need to beat us over the head with the fact that it was a mystery in the same way that Spyfall — and especially Spyfall Part One — did.

I didn't time it precisely, but I'm pretty sure that the "five minutes" that the Judoon gave The Doctor stretched out more than a bit.
I didn’t time it precisely, but I’m pretty sure that the “five minutes” that the Judoon gave The Doctor stretched out more than a bit.

Instead, the story evolves slowly, leaving the mystery of the fugitive mostly open the entire way through.

Q:How does Steve The Judoon whistle?
A: He just puts his lips together and… Blos.

Now, there is one issue here for much newer Who fans, and that’s the fact that beyond Captain Jack, there’s a lot of callbacks in this episode. Unless you remember the Chameleon Arch (from “Family of Blood” of course and later “Utopia”), then the reveal that Ruth is in fact a Time Lord — and a very specific Time Lord if the story’s primary narrative is reliable. Again, we’ll have to wait and see how that plays out.

Q:Why did the Judoon Military Commander water her crops?
A: Because she wanted them to Gro.

As with last week’s Nikola Tesla’s Night Of Terror, the quality of the story rests not just on the story but also on the performances of the actors within, and there’s plenty of credit to hand around. The transformation of Jo Martin’s Ruth into The Doctor, and the way she handles everything from Venusian Akido (which clearly works on the Judoon) to her change not only of costume but also of tone and body language is handled masterfully. I’d totally watch a series of Doctor Who with her as the Doctor — presuming that she is indeed The Doctor at all.

Q: Why don’t the Judoon like holidaying on the Ood planet?
A: Too much… sno.

Equal plaudits, though, for Jodie Whittaker, who finally gets some scenes with material she can really chew on as an actor, facing up to the double whammy of meeting, well, herself and the return of both Captain Jack and Gallifrey in one fell swoop. Again, at least as far as we know. The emotion writ large on Whittaker’s face looking out over a ruined Gallifrey, and her speeches to the Tardis crew are just exemplary.

Q: Why are the Judoon big Captain Jack Harkness fans?
A: Because he’s the face of… Boe.

The heavy lifting by Whittaker and Martin does reduce the roles for Ryan, Graham and Yaz to much more supporting roles, not entirely helped by them being whisked around to wherever the plot needs them to go.

Gallifrey is gone. It burned. Except in the past it didn't, so it's still alive. But it did, and will have. Also, The Master said everything you know is a lie. So... yeah. What we know is that we don't know, and everything else is guesswork.
Gallifrey is gone. It burned. Except in the past it didn’t, so it’s still alive. But it did, and will have. Also, The Master said everything you know is a lie. So… yeah. What we know is that we don’t know, and everything else is guesswork.

I was slightly worried that Captain Jack’s magical time scoop — my better half suggests it might have come his way via Gallifrey’s Death Zone, which would fit with how accurate it wasn’t — would magically “return” the Tardis crew straight to The Doctor, but that would have utterly muddled the reveal scenes for the new Doctor.

Ultimately split — because I have to be — on just how good Fugitive Of The Judoon actually is. It’s wildly enjoyable in itself, but a lot of it does rest on where the story goes from here. Which was much the same story as with Spyfall Part One, but the quality acting and even the more relaxed direction not beating me over the head with the fact that there’s an underlying mystery leaves me wanting more. Much more, in fact.

Other smaller observations and thoughts

  • Some beautiful misdirection into why and how Lee both was and wasn’t a fugitive, although as soon as Gat killed him, it became rather obvious that it had to be Ruth as the primary target.
  • For the “fans” (and I use the term lightly) who lost their minds when there was a female Doctor… there are now two of them. And they’re wonderful!
  • I’d totally live on that lighthouse… as long as there was decent broadband.
  • I’m not sold that Jo Martin is is The Doctor, if only because of the booby trapped gun. Sure, there’s the nice joke about her not using it on the Judoon, but she did know it was booby trapped before she allowed Gat to fire it. A core part of the actual Doctor’s character is the avoidance of violence without fair warning. That wasn’t fair warning by any measure, and that’s leaving aside anyone else who dies as a result of Ruth’s fugitive status. The script for future episodes is going to have a hard time explaining that away.
  • That being said, if she is canonically going to be The Doctor, then where does she fit? That gap between Troughton’s forced regeneration? A post-War-Doctor-Pre-Eccleston Doctor? Pre-Hartnell?
  • The other clue, of course, is the complete lack of mention of the Blinovitch Limitation Effect. Mawdryn would be spinning in his non-existent graves!
  • How did The Doctor — the Ruth Doctor, that is — bury The Tardis? More to the point, why?
  • The Ruth Doctor’s Tardis has roundels. I love the roundels, and I’m not ashamed to say so.
  • Equally obviously, I have no shame when it comes to terrible Judoon jokes.

And now the tricky task of…

Ranking the episodes of Season 12 of Doctor Who!

  1. Nikola Tesla’s Night Of Terror
  2. Fugitive Of The Judoon
  3. Spyfall Part Two
  4. Spyfall Part One
  5. .
  6. .
  7. .
  8. .
  9. .
  10. Orphan 55

Fugitive Of The Judoon was way more enjoyable than I thought it would be based on the trailer. Still, I’ll put Tesla ahead of it (for now) because that story stands on its own feet, whereas the real effective story telling behind Fugitive won’t be known until the rest of the series concludes — or however long it takes for the story to unfold. I may revise that ranking later on.

Next week: Praxeus. Whatever that is, unfolding all around the globe!

Images: BBC

Author: Alex

Alex Kidman is a multi-award winning Australian technology writer, former editor at Gizmodo, CNET, GameSpot, ZDNet, PC Mag, APC, Finder and as a contributor to the ABC, SMH, AFR, Courier Mail, GadgetGuy, PC & Tech Authority, Atomic and many more. He's been writing professionally since 1998, and his passions include technology, social issues, education, retro gaming and professional wrestling.

1 thought on “Doctor Who: Fugitive Of The Judoon Review

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.